Costellos Butcher and Deli

Had a great shopping experience being our first time in the store! My son and I were greeted with a warm welcome and excellent customer service. They gave my son a free lunch. He felt like he won the lottery. What a great program to serve our young community! They have a wonderful variety of products. A great selection of wine, spices, cheeses, meats, Wagyu! and so much more.

First Time shopper, Staff were friendly and knowledgeable suggested my wife and I try the pork chops which were delicious. That all being said we went to Costellos for Beef Ribs. Spent 42 dollars on a slab of four ribs. Trimming the fat this morning and 1/3 of it is just hard fat cap down to the bone. I'm just a dad trying to burn some meat for his family and maybe I made a bad pick on a rack of ribs but it feels bad and wasn't what I expected after the wonderful experience I had in the store.

Visited the other day and found Costellos friendly, welcoming and very busy. Don’t let the small building mislead you. They have a lot of variety of high quality meats and cheeses as well as a Boar’s head sandwich shop. The owners and staff are super friendly and knowledgeable. Their charitable efforts are widely recognized and appreciated in the community. I was there and witnessed Darren offer up free lunches to all children who come in. They had their choice of meat and cheese or pb&j with milk and an apple. It was heartwarming to see. Great selection of wines, desserts as well as fresh local meats and poultry. All kinds of butchery with wagyu beef, elk, bison, local turkey and great deals on ground beef mix with beef tenderloin at a great price. I will definitely be returning soon. 100% recommendation for you to stop by for a visit. Don’t miss this opportunity if you’re down that way. They also have a food truck there but I’m not sure about hours of operation. Urban Cowgill July 2025

We love Costellos! We moved to Georgia from Pensacola. Every trip we make to Pcola, we stop in and grab some exotic meats to take back to Georgia! On this trip, we were able to get some authentic Italian Olive Oil. Very friendly people/staff!

Hands down the most extraordinary experience! Darren is so full of knowledge and passion! Awesome prices and a wide selection of meats, cheeses, and authentic Italian ingredients along with great customer service - you're missing out if you don't give them a try!

Really good but small meat market. They had their filet mix hamburger on sale, so we bought 3 lbs for burgers. The meat had a good taste with not a lot of fat. This was our first visit but it won't be our last.

Great sandwiches and chips! Super friendly staff! We walked in and this beautiful lady, both outside and inside just started loading my daughter and son up with free food! Come to find out she feeds all the area kids that stop in everyday! We didn’t need it or ask for it. I don’t know her name but she’s an angel! We bought sandwiches and some steaks. Both were amazing!!! Great selection of food and they make sure you don’t leave unless you’re 100% satisfied! I will be back, without a doubt!

Every steak I purchase from here is top notch! The quality is amazing. I also purchase wine here each time I visit and there’s always a gentleman that comes to check if I have any questions! I don’t recall his name, but he’s probably my favorite part of Costello’s! These are two wines I picked up and the steak after I cooked it! I recommend both of these wines. They are very different from one another. One is slightly sweet and full of fruit forward taste (Pinot) and then one is peppery with a darker fruit forward taste.

Costello’s is the Butcher shop and deli you might remember from the classic movies, or from your childhood. Where everyone there excels in customer service, every sandwich they make is excellent, and they actually care about their community. From feeding kids that come in their store throughout the pandemic to the amazing deli sandwiches, excellent hospitality, selections of meats, steaks, cheeses, and everything else you’d want in at a deli. We try a different sandwich each week and I will update this review with more pictures as I return. Check it out and enjoy! 5 of 5 stars easily.

The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable. Anything they don’t have out in the displays they will always check the back to see if they have any. Owners are always out greeting customers and giving advice in the best way to cook the meats and making recommendations on what seasonings to use. The last time we went we brought our son and they gave him a free lunch for the summer that included multiple breakfast items, drinks, desserts and lunch items. Our son was so excited and said this is his favorite store now!

The owner himself came out and welcomed us and explained so many things to my wife and I. He also allowed us to sample a few of their meats and cheese. We each ordered a deli sandwich and it’s the most delicious sandwich’s that we’ve ever …

Awesome meat and spices, great prices. You will find meat here that you find no where else. They have some great, local made pies too. Items directly from Italy also.

The staff are very pleasant to work with. Also if you ask they will cut or grind your meat to order. Also they have Wagu meats available and exotic meats. I suggest the camel 🐫 it doesn't have a gamey flavor and is as tender as a beef tenderloin. …

Okay, I'll come right out and say that Costellos is the only place I will ever buy meat from in town! This place is the best! They make the best Sandwiches too. Allways a treat to stop in and deal with their extremely knowledgeable and …

Very friendly employees. We got the filet mignon. I smoked it and then seared on the grill. It was melt in your mouth tender and so delicious. Love all the seasonings too. We will definitely be going back.

Friendly, well priced and well stocked deli. They have a large selection of meats, some desserts and sides, along with a counter where you can order sandwices. This place lives up to its great reputation!

Elevated our cooking could not be happier, the service, price, and quality was fantastic

My husband and I shared a Kimmie sandwich. It was soooooooo good! The flavor combination, spicy mustard, hot pepper jelly, and roasted red peppers, along with others was a perfect mix! The staff is amazing and very helpful, felt like ordering from friends who want you to have the best. We will be back.

Great Ribeyes. While your there grab some 3.99 per pound ground hamburger. You won't be disappointed.

Always excellent options. Very diverse selections and everything is always great quality. Employees are always friendly and helpful. They have the best steaks around.